26 BBC Football Pundits Predict their Top 4 for the 2023/24 Season

Football pundits predictions

The new Premier League season is about to get underway and the full team of BBC football pundits have predicted how they think the top 4 will look come the end of the season.

All of the BBC pundits have had a go at predicting which four teams will qualify for the Champions League including the likes of Micah Richards, Leon Osman, Glenn Murray, Danny Murphy and Chris Sutton.

Unsurprisingly, there is overwhelming support for Manchester City to retain their Premier League title again, with no less than 25 pundits predicting Pep Guardiola’s side will be top of the table next May. Only Ellen WHite made a different prediction, going for Arsenal to go one better than last season’s second place finish.

21 of the BBC pundits expect Arsenal to finish 2nd behind Man City, with Leon Osman and Steve Sidwell going for Manchester United to finish in second spot and Shay Given the only one to put Liverpool in second place.

The two dominant teams expected to finish 3rd are Liverpool and Manchester United but there were two votes for Newcastle, from Pat Nevin and Chris Waddle and a shout for Chelsea by Glenn Murray.

Fourth spot has a couple of shouts for Newcastle and also two for Aston Villa on the BBC pundits table predictor. Both Ellen White and Stephen Warnock are predicting Villa will get into the top four this season and Danny Gabbidon was the only pundit predicting a fourth place finish for Chelsea.


BBC Pundits Top 4 Predictions

Predictor 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
Ellen White Arsenal Man City Man Utd Aston Villa
Stephen Warnock Man City Arsenal Liverpool Aston Villa
Fara Williams Man City Chelsea Arsenal Man Utd
Leon Osman Man City Man Utd Arsenal Liverpool
Steve Sidwell Man City Man Utd Liverpool Arsenal
Lindsay Johnson Man City Arsenal Man Utd Newcastle
Chris Waddle Man City Arsenal Newcastle Man Utd
Pat Nevin Man City Arsenal Newcastle Liverpool
Shay Given Man City Liverpool Arsenal Newcastle
Glenn Murray Man City Arsenal Chelsea Man Utd
Danny Gabbidon Man City Arsenal Liverpool Chelsea
Chris Sutton Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Sue Smith Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Dion Dublin Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Michael Brown Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Karen Bardsley Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Jermaine Beckford Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Matt Upson Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Ashley Williams Man City Arsenal Man Utd Liverpool
Martin Keown Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Micah Richards Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Anita Asante Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Nedum Onuoha Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Danny Murphy Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Clinton Morrison Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd
Rob Green Man City Arsenal Liverpool Man Utd


Key Quotes from the BBC Pundits

Micah Richards on Man City: Their squad is still better than everyone else’s. They won’t win the Treble again, but they will win the Premier League.

Chris Sutton on Man City: The other top clubs have done some very good work in this transfer window but you can’t look past City for the title. Guardiola evolves something every year – some tweak to his tactics will emerge and another player always seems to step in and become key.

Martin Keown on Arsenal: Of course I really want Arsenal to win the Premier League – as a pundit I am impartial, but as a former Arsenal player I am excited because last season was the first time in many years that we felt we were back in the fight and the team was competitive. It was a hell of a ride for the 248 days we were top of the table, and I don’t expect that form to disappear.

Ellen White on Arsenal: Arsenal were so close last year and they have added to their squad really well. They need Jesus back because I don’t think Havertz is a number nine, but they won’t be short of goals – I am a big fan of Leandro Trossard.

Steve Sidwell on Arsenal: Arsenal were immense last season and the culture and environment Mikel Arteta has created is evident on the pitch. They will fall short of the title again, but still secure another top-four spot.

Danny Murphy on Man Utd: I am a bit worried about United, in a positive way for them but a negative way for everyone else. I really like the business that Erik ten Hag has done.

Chris Waddle on Man Utd: Hojlund is young and unproven, and he has not scored that many goals, but he will set the tempo for the team and let United play on the front foot – if he leads the press, everyone will back him up. But they need to be challenging for the title, not just the top four – and I don’t see that happening this season.

Shay Given on Liverpool: Liverpool are going to make a serious comeback this season. They have freshened it up in midfield of course, but I just think they will be stronger everywhere and hungry to get back to competing at the top of the table.

Leon Osman on Liverpool: They have lost a lot of leadership over the summer and they still haven’t got enough energy in midfield.

Pat Nevin on Chelsea: I’ve got to be absolutely honest, I haven’t got a clue how Chelsea are going to do, and that’s unusual. Sometimes, though, you have to put your hands up and say it is so random that they are just as likely to be top four or top six as they are to be the same as they were last season – in the bottom half, and have a nightmare.

Fara Williams on Chelsea: With Chelsea not in the Champions League, and Mauricio Pochettino bringing the group together, they have a real chance to focus on the Premier League. He has done it before, with Tottenham… and they might surprise a few people.

Chris Waddle on Newcastle: Eddie Howe has done a great job because, when you look at their team on paper compared to the other sides up there, you wouldn’t say Newcastle are a top-four team. I’m expecting more of the same this year, though, which is why I am backing them to make it again. They were terrific at home, they were solid defensively and there was a real buzz about the way they played.

The only problem I see with them is still who is going to get them goals, because they don’t score enough. Callum Wilson is a poacher but he has fitness issues, and Alexander Isak seems to prefer to come and join in the build-up.

Ellen White on Aston Villa: I really liked the way Villa played under Unai Emery last season – it wasn’t just their results which were impressive when they were flying up the table.

Matt Upson on Aston Villa: Emery had an amazing impact but sustaining that form for an entire campaign is very different. Have they got enough quality, in depth, to finish in the top four? I’m not sure about that.

Nedum Onuoha on Tottenham: I’ve gone for Spurs to finish fifth and get the extra Champions League spot for 2024-25 that will go to the two countries with the best record in European club competition this season.

Matt Upson on Tottenham: Spurs are miles off my radar. I’d pick Brighton to finish above them and having a better chance of making the top four. The Seagulls essentially had a top-four season last season but they were robbed of at least four points by VAR – they even got an apology about it – and then the FA Cup semi-final defeat finished them because they lost all momentum and didn’t seem quite the same after that.

Pundits Predictions this Season

See Paul Merson’s score predictions for each Premier League game.

Lawro makes his predictions for this season.

Michael Owen predicts the final Premier League table.

Sky Sports pundit Jones Knows predicts the scores this weekend.

Premier League Free Bet Offers

Betfred Sign-up Offer, Promo Codes and Welcome Offer: Bet £10 get £50 in Bonuses Betfred Sign-up Offer, Promo Codes and Welcome Offer: Bet £10 get £50 in Bonuses

Bet £10 get £50 in Free Bets & Bonuses

✔️Generous sign-up offer of £50
✔️Loads of different betting markets
✔️Well known brand in the UK

New customers only. Register (excl. 13/04/24) with WELCOME50. First bet £10+ at Evens (2.0)+ on Sports within 7 days to get Free Bets: £20 In-Play, £20 Acca & 50 x £0.20 (£10) Free Spins on Fishin’ Frenzy within 10 hours of settlement. 7-day expiry. Eligibility & payment exclusions apply. Full T&Cs apply.

Bet £25 get a £50 Free Bet

✔️£50 free bet when you bet £25
✔️Promo code BB50 gets the offer
✔️Relatively new bookies

New Players Only. Min £ 25 qualifying bets stake not returned. Free bet - one-time stake of £ 50, min odds 1.5, stake not returned. 1X wager the winnings. Wager from real balance first. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Max conversion: £200. Valid for 7 Days from issue. Withdrawal requests void all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms apply. 18+. Begambleaware.org. #ad

Bet £10 get £40 in Free Bets

18+ New customers only. Opt in, bet £10  on any football market at minimum 1/1 odds. No cash out. Get £40 in Free Bets on selected events. Free Bets expire in 7 days. Debit card / Apple Pay payments only. T&Cs apply, see below. begambleaware.org | Please gamble responsibly

Bet £10 get £50 in Free Bets & No Deposit £5

Full T&Cs apply. New UK customers only. The qualifying bet should be either 1 Single or Accumulator (2+ selections) bet, start at £10, and have 1.9 or greater odds. 5 Free bets include: 1 x £10 Free bet on horse racing, 1 x £10 Free bet on football, 2 x 10 Free bet in-play, 1 x £10 Free bet Acca. Max payout – £500. 7 day expiry. 18+ only. Begambleaware.com.
bet365 Sign-up Offer – Bet £10 get £30 in Free Bets for New Customers bet365 Sign-up Offer – Bet £10 get £30 in Free Bets for New Customers

Bet £10 Get £30 in Free Bets

✔️Our top rated bookmaker
✔️Great existing customer offers
✔️Competitive odds on football

Min deposit requirement. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits and are available for use upon settlement of bets to value of qualifying deposit. Min odds, bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. Time limits and T&Cs apply. Registration required.

Relevant news